Thanksgiving Pie Menu 2025| Sweet & Savory Pies

Sweet, Savory, and Everything In Between—Plus 15% Off When You Order by 10/31

Let's talk about Thanksgiving.

The gathering. The gratitude. The moments around the table with people you love. Those are the parts worth savoring.

The hours of prep work? The stress of timing everything perfectly? The endless dishes? Not so much.

This year, we're here to help you focus on what matters—spending quality time with loved ones instead of spending all day in the kitchen. Whether you need help with dessert, dinner, or both, we've got you covered with our complete Thanksgiving menu.

And here's the best part: Order by October 31st and save 15% with code "THANKSGIVING15".

Something for Everyone at Your Thanksgiving Table

We know every family does Thanksgiving a little differently. Some of you are traditionalists who love a classic 9" pie at the center of the table. Others want to celebrate everyone's individual tastes with a variety of flavors so each person can choose their favorite.

Good news: we've got both covered.

Thanksgiving 12-Pack: Individual Flavors for Every Guest

Perfect for families who want variety or households where pie preferences run deep. Our Thanksgiving 12-Pack includes:

Apple Crumb - Classic fall comfort with a buttery crumb topping
Apple Cranberry - Tart meets sweet in perfect harmony
Cherry Crumb - Because some people are Team Cherry all the way
Pecan - Great-Grandmother Maude's famous recipe with San Saba pecans
Pumpkin (with decorative leaf cutout) - Traditional pumpkin pie, beautiful presentation
Texas Two Step - Pecan pie meets chocolate brownie for the best of both worlds

With the 12-pack, everyone gets to pick their favorite flavor.

Not So Tiny Pies: Traditional 9" Size for Classic Celebrations

If you're a traditionalist who loves the ritual of slicing and serving a full-size pie, our Not So Tiny pies are your answer. Available in:

Apple Crumb - Buttery, spiced apples with our signature crumb topping
Pumpkin Chai - Traditional pumpkin with chai whipped cream
Pecan - Four generations of Texas pecan pie perfection
Chocolate Cream - Rich, silky chocolate for the chocolate lovers at your table
Pumpkin Cheesecake - Where pumpkin pie meets creamy cheesecake luxury

Each Not So Tiny pie serves 6-8 people and makes a beautiful centerpiece for your Thanksgiving table.

Don't Want to Cook Thanksgiving Dinner? We've Got You.

Here's a secret: not everyone loves cooking a full Thanksgiving spread. Maybe you're hosting for the first time. Maybe you're exhausted from a busy fall. Maybe you'd rather spend the day watching football and enjoying family instead of sweating over a hot stove.

Whatever your reason, we won't judge. We'll just help.

Turkey Pot Pie: Thanksgiving Dinner in a Pie

Our 5" Turkey Pot Pie is literally Thanksgiving dinner, reimagined:

Classic turkey filling
Cornbread stuffing
Cranberry sauce
Creamy mashed potato topping
All baked in our signature Tiny Pies crust

It's got every element of a traditional Thanksgiving plate, wrapped up in flaky pastry. Your guests will think you've been cooking all day. We won't tell if you don't.

Beef Pot Pie: For the Non-Turkey Fans

Not everyone is a turkey person, and that's okay. Our 5" Beef Pot Pie features Natural Angus beef with fresh vegetables and herbs in rich, savory filling. It's comfort food that rivals any Thanksgiving main dish.

Both pot pies are available for your Thanksgiving menu, giving you flexibility to serve what your family actually wants to eat.

Here's How It Works

Order by October 31st and use code THANKSGIVING15 at checkout for 15% off your entire Thanksgiving order.

Pick up Monday through Wednesday before Thanksgiving (November 24-26, 2025).

Heat and serve on Thanksgiving Day. No one needs to know they weren't homemade. Seriously. We won't tell.

You get to spend the holiday with your loved ones instead of in the kitchen. That's what Thanksgiving should be about.

From Our Kitchen to Your Table

We're incredibly honored that Great-Grandmother Maude's pies—recipes that have been in our founder's family for four generations—will be gracing your Thanksgiving table this year.

When we bake these pies, we think about Maude and the care she put into her baking. We think about the generations of family gatherings where her recipes brought people together. And now, we get to be part of your family's Thanksgiving tradition.

That's not something we take lightly. We're grateful for the trust you place in us when you choose Tiny Pies for your holiday celebrations.

Make This Thanksgiving About What Matters

The perfect Thanksgiving isn't about spending all day cooking. It's about:

Laughter around the table
Stories shared over pie
Kids running around while adults catch up
That moment when everyone's full and happy and grateful to be together

Let us handle the pies (and maybe dinner too). You focus on making memories.

Order Your Thanksgiving Menu Now

15% OFF when you order by October 31st
Use code: THANKSGIVING15 at checkout

Thanksgiving 12-Pack - Individual pies in 6 delicious flavors
Not So Tiny Pies - Traditional 9" pies, serves 6-8
Savory Pot Pies - Turkey or Beef, 5" size

Pick up: Monday-Wednesday, November 24-26, 2025

Order Now

Small-batch. Made with care. Ready to make your Thanksgiving easier and more delicious.

Your Thanksgiving Table, Made Easier (And More Delicious)